Top 5 Wednesday: 2018 Wishlist


Top Five Wednesday was created by Lainey from gingerreadslainey and is currently hosted by Sam from Thoughts on Tomes. Check out the goodreads group to learn more.

December 27th: 2018 Wishlist
–Looking forward into the new year, this is a list of the types of books you’d like to see more of in 2018! Try to avoid actual titles, and discuss themes, genres, or tropes you’d like to see more of in the new year!

Yes, it’s Thursday, but let’s just…pretend it’s still Wednesday. Yesterday I went to bed at 9pm instead of writing this post, and then I woke up at 12:30pm the next day. Yes, that’s about fifteen hours of sleep. The worst part? This isn’t out of the ordinary for me.

Anyway! There are plenty of things I’m dying to see in the books I read, especially YA fantasy, so it was difficult narrowing down to just five!

Female Friendships: I’m gonna bet this is a popular wish, since it’s so woefully lacking! Yes, things have been getting a tad better, but most female friendships really only pay lip service to the idea while being sacrificed for what I like to call the Inexplicable Heterosexual Romance.  Warsan Shire once said, “There is no intimacy like that between two women who have chosen to be sisters.” I want to see more of that, a true intimacy between women. And frankly, given that most YA fantasies take place in pseudo-medieval times, it only makes sense that women would have close friendships with other women.  In this same vein, I want to see more fully-fleshed, complex female characters who are not the protagonists.

Lesbians: I want more f/f relationships in fantasy, and I don’t want those books to then be relegated to “special interest” or something like that. We’ve been seeing a decent amount of m/m relationships in stories, but f/f relationships are sorely, sorely lacking, and it’s disheartening.  I want a f/f relationship that is front and center in a book that’s considered mainstream.  (Disclaimer: I say “lesbians” but of course I also mean women who are bixesual, pansexual, etc, in relationships with women.)

Standalone Fantasy: She says, as she writes her own fantasy trilogy. But seriously.  I have nothing against the trend of trilogies and duologies, but it would be nice to see a standalone fantasy here and there. I get that trilogies are better money-makers but a lot of times a story is actually made much worse when it is stretched out so much. Some stories only need one book to be told.  Also, speaking as someone with a horrible memory, I often have to reread the entire series whenever a sequel comes out, since I can never remember anything that happened.  Oh, I also wouldn’t mind a trilogy of separate stories that takes place in the same world, however (this is actually what I’m writing)!

Realistic Romance: From my reviews, you would think that I detest romance in my books. This is actually not true! I detest badly written, heteronormative, misogynistic, cliched romance. Often this Inexplicable Heterosexual Romance will eclipse everything else just so that it can exist; I can’t tell you how many books I’ve read where the protagonist falls in love with a random guy for no reason at all and it makes no sense. It always makes me roll my eyes. But good romance? It’s rare but it’s so worth waiting for.  Examples include Kaz and Inej from Six of Crows, Kell and Lila from Shades of Magic, and Hanani and Wanu from the Dreamblood duology. All three are slow burn, develop organically, and are realistically presented.  Also, none of them take over the main plot.

Realistic Male Characters: Often in YA fantasy male characters will be either a) assholes with hearts of gold, apparently or b) super duper nice and perfect.  Either way, they’re usually unrealistic wish-fulfillment of some kind.  I would love to see more male characters who actually are jerks and stay that way, who are cowards, who are soft boys and stay soft, who can’t commit, who lie and manipulate, who are insecure…just, something more realistic! I want to see young men with actual flaws.  Give me more Kaz Brekkers and Kell Mareshes, you know? In all likelihood this will also make the romances more bearable.

Agree, disagree? Do you have some recommendations for me based on these wishes? What are some things you want to see in 2018? Comment and let me know!

12 thoughts on “Top 5 Wednesday: 2018 Wishlist

    1. Yeah, I know what you mean! This year I read three, two of which were okay: The Library of Fates and Long May She Reign. The third was actually incredible, but it was very much fantasy lite, more a novel of manners than fantasy: The Beautiful Ones.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. YES. Realistic female friendships are so great. I definitely feel that there aren’t enough of them in YA, which is really sad. Same with realistic male characters – it’s so rare to find male characters in YA that truly act like teenage boys. Thanks for sharing and, as always, fabulous post! ❤


  2. Yes!! This is such a fantastic list and I agree with so much of what you have said. I am so desperate for more female friendships and female friendships that are actually presented as important and not just a side note to the romance! One of my favourite quotes is ‘friendships between women are often the deepest and most profound love stories’. Also definite yes to stand-alone fantasy! I am so put off from starting fantasy books because I have a really bad case of reading amnesia so in the time between releases I completely forget what’s happened. Unless I am completely desperate to read a particular series, these days I wait until all of the books have been released and then read them close together! 🙂


    1. That is such a beautiful quote! Seriously, I can’t get over how amazing it is!

      I totally do the same with certain fantasy series! Like I just know I won’t be able to remember all the details I need to remember so I wait for the whole thing to come out. I feel guilty because I know if everyone did that and no one bought the first book then the rest of the series would suffer from low sales and not be published, but alas! We can only hope other people have better memories than us! 😉

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’m glad you like the quote, I love it too! I first saw it over on Tumblr as part of a gifset of Phoebe, Monica and Rachel from Friends and just fell completely in love with it. Haha definitely, and be totally jealous of them! 😂😂

        Liked by 1 person

  3. This is such a great list!! I’d love more stand-alone fantasies. I think all the series is what makes fantasy feel like a big commitment a lot of the time? I mean I love fantasy series, but I think I’d read more fantasy if I didn’t always feel like I need to devote myself to multiple books every time I’m in the mood for it.


    1. Oh, absolutely. I can’t tell you how many fantasies I want to read but don’t have the time or energy to committ to! Some series are GIGANTIC; like I really want to read the Malazan series but it’s like twelve books??? Madness.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s